Back to John Thomas Donnelly’s journal
When Hope Is the Most Dangerous Thing in the Room
Richard Yates understood that disappointment rarely arrives from outside a life. It grows inside the story people tell themselves about who they were meant to become.
You could describe Revolutionary Road as a novel about a bad marriage in the suburbs.
That description is accurate in the way a weather report is accurate. It tells you where the storm is and leaves out what it feels like to stand in the kitchen while the windows shake.
Yates begins with a community-theatre production that goes wrong. The actors know it has gone wrong. Their friends know. What follows is not honesty but consolation, which is one of the first adult rituals his characters perform together. Everyone agrees to protect the evening from the evidence of the evening.
The rest of the novel grows from that arrangement. Frank and April Wheeler do not simply lie to one another. They collaborate on a finer version of themselves, then punish each other when ordinary life refuses to confirm it. Frank wants to believe his dissatisfaction proves he is meant for something larger. April wants departure to become a practical act of rescue. Their plan for Paris is moving because they need it, dangerous because they need it, and almost impossible to discuss without turning one person's hope into the other person's accusation.
Yates never lets the dream become noble merely because the life around it is disappointing. That is the part I love. He understands the vanity hidden inside unhappiness. He knows people can be genuinely wounded and still arrange the account in their favour. He knows a person may describe a marriage with painful accuracy and remain almost entirely mistaken about himself.
This is not cynicism. Cynicism would be easier. A cynical writer can stand outside the room and despise everybody in it. Yates stays close enough to notice the little salvage operations: the drink poured with unnecessary care, the good shirt worn to a bad conversation, the rehearsed sentence that is supposed to restore dignity and instead exposes need.
He does not spare his characters, but he does not make them specimens. Their humiliations matter because their hopes matter.
In Eleven Kinds of Loneliness, that world is wider and harsher. The sadness is not confined to one marriage or one Connecticut road. It appears in offices, schools, rented rooms, hospital wards and the temporary alliances people form because the truth would leave them with nobody to talk to. These are not exceptional failures. They are ordinary people discovering that wanting a better life does not give them the equipment to make one.
Then there is The Easter Parade, where two sisters take different routes through adulthood and neither route proves morally superior. Yates has no interest in rewarding one woman for choosing domestic life or congratulating the other for choosing independence. Time passes. Injuries acquire manners. People learn which facts can be mentioned at lunch.
He is often called bleak, which is fair but incomplete. Bleakness is an atmosphere. Yates is interested in pressure.
He applies it to the sentence people have built their lives around: I am different. I was meant for more. Once this changes, I will become myself. He waits until the sentence has to survive money, work, sex, children, illness, disappointment and the terrible persistence of personality.
Usually it does survive. That is the tragedy.
The hope in Yates is stubborn enough to keep damaging the people who carry it. Frank does not stop believing in the superior self waiting somewhere beyond his present life. Emily Grimes does not stop reaching for a version of love that will settle the argument she has been having with herself. His characters are not destroyed because they have no hope. They are destroyed because hope can be made to excuse almost anything.
That recognition sits close to the question inside They Called It Love Anyway. I was less interested in whether people loved one another than in what they permitted themselves to do while calling it love. Affection does not erase injury. Loyalty does not make the family account accurate. A person can sincerely want rescue and still make somebody else pay for it.
Yates knew that sincerity was never an acquittal.
I love him because he does not confuse exposure with change. A character may understand the trap and continue decorating it. A marriage may finally tell the truth and remain a marriage. A life may be seen clearly for one minute before habit closes over it again.
Near the end of Revolutionary Road, a small domestic gesture turns listening itself into a choice. Yates does not explain the symbol or ask the reader to admire the workmanship. He simply leaves one person talking and another person deciding how much of the truth he wishes to hear.
That is where Yates leaves us most often: not without hope, but without the comforting belief that hope is innocent.
He looked at ordinary disappointment and understood that it had an inner life. He gave it appetite, vanity, humour, tenderness and a good vocabulary. Then he refused to rescue anyone from the consequences of using those gifts badly.
I keep returning because he never mistakes mercy for a happy ending.