Back to John Thomas Donnelly’s journal
The Story He No Longer Likes
I become suspicious when someone says a person has changed and leaves the charge there, as though the rest of us had agreed to remain available in our original condition. I become suspicious, and then I recognise how much reassurance I take from people being recognisable. The same complaint, the same extravagant opinion about an unimportant matter. There you are. I know how to sit beside you.
A familiar story can do that work. I like the kind in which the teller loses some dignity along the way, preferably without noticing until the others have begun to laugh. There is a generous amount of room in a story like that. Someone who has heard it can wait for the favourite part; someone new can be brought in without an examination. I would defend a certain amount of repetition on these grounds. Probably more than the people listening would consider reasonable.
Put four invented friends around a table. One begins an old account of the youngest getting hopelessly lost on the way to an important appointment. There is a wrongly read sign, a borrowed coat, a telephone call made with great confidence from entirely the wrong place. The youngest has always laughed. This evening, before the telephone call, he asks whether they could give it a rest.
I dislike how quickly I want to supply him with a reason. A bad day, perhaps. Something private. With a sufficient explanation I could protect the evening and preserve my good opinion of everybody, including the teller, whom I have already begun to like. Yet he might simply be tired of this being his entrance into the company. He might want to arrive carrying something other than that coat.
The teller, meanwhile, has put down his fork. I would feel for him. An affectionate habit has become a small public offence without any warning he considers adequate. He may be the friend who would drive out in foul weather to fetch the youngest from a genuinely wrong place. I don't want that care cancelled by one graceless response at dinner. Nor do I want to use it to purchase another performance from the person being teased.
This is where my account starts going round again. I find another consideration, then another, and take some comfort in being the person willing to consider them. It postpones choosing whose discomfort can be allowed to remain at the table. In the meantime the youngest might be smiling, helping the others escape the difficulty he has caused by asking for very little. I would be grateful for that smile. I would have to examine the gratitude.
There is no need to abolish the story. The teller can remember it, and the coat can remain absurd. I would like him to leave out the telephone call this time and ask the youngest about something happening now. An awkward question would do. Nobody needs to become wonderfully perceptive before the plates are cleared.
I still want the friendship to feel like the same friendship. That is the awkward part for me. I can approve of another person's freedom in principle and quietly expect him to exercise it without disturbing anything I love. I would like to think I could let the silence go on for a while. I am less certain that I wouldn't try another story.