Back to John Thomas Donnelly’s journal
The Road Never Promised to Save Us
I love the sheer crowding of Born to Run: more people, more noise and more urgency than seem possible to fit inside a song. Everybody is trying to get somewhere. You can feel the hurry before you've worked out where they mean to go.
The promise of escape is only part of it. Anybody can promise that. What matters is the terrible amount of hope his people have invested in a car, a street, a lover, a Friday night. The engines are loud because the lives behind them are small, and the people living those lives have no intention of admitting defeat just yet.
The music can sound triumphant while the people inside it are frightened. You can turn it up and celebrate, or you can listen closely and hear how much is at stake if the car doesn't start.
For a writer so closely associated with leaving, Springsteen has an awful lot of people who stay. Others try to leave and can't, or discover that the geography has changed without curing a single thing. Darkness on the Edge of Town didn't offer the adolescent permission that Born to Run seemed to offer. It made room for pride, badly paid work, old obligations and the anger that comes from doing everything you're supposed to do and finding there is still not enough at the end of the week.
That anger is different from self-pity. A man can be furious with the world and still get up for work. He can love his family and resent what keeping them requires. He can feel loyal to a place whose best opportunities seem reserved for somebody else. Springsteen allows those thoughts to exist together. He doesn't clean them up to make his characters admirable.
The first-time listener hears the road. The lifelong listener hears the kitchen after everyone else has gone to bed. The unpaid bill sits beside the keys. Somebody has said something cruel and wishes it could be taken back. Somebody else is waiting for an apology that will probably arrive as a repaired fence or a full tank of petrol instead of an actual sentence. These aren't quotations from his songs. They are the private inscriptions a listener carries away from them.
In The River, a relationship can be real and still fail the people who believe in it. A promise can be made sincerely at twenty and become an obligation at thirty. There are moments in those songs when love is all someone has, and other moments when love is what makes the room impossible to leave. That distinction matters to me.
Then came Nebraska, and much of the company vanished. A voice, a guitar, a thin recording that seemed barely protected from the room around it. No large band to insist that a worse day would be followed by a better one. The people on that record made choices that could not be undone; some committed terrible acts, some merely ran out of decent options, and some kept travelling because stopping would mean looking at what they had become. Yet the record was not an exercise in despair. Every so often a human gesture survived that should not have survived.
In They Called It Love Anyway, Adam Weller's attachment to Nebraska is intensely private; he is not a fan in the usual sense. Conor O'Roarke borrows a phrase from “Open All Night” and turns it toward rescue. Cynthia makes “Atlantic City” into a promise the song does not quite offer. Adam resents what they have taken from the record, but his own reading is hardly innocent. He has found an explanation there that he needs rather too badly.
I don't need every reader to notice that. I hope the people who know the record will recognize something in him without being told to.
I particularly love his refusal to write off people who have to go back in on Monday. He knows the humiliation of wanting more than your wages, your town or your courage can buy. He knows that loyalty can be a virtue and a prison, sometimes on the same afternoon. He knows that being disappointed is not the same thing as being finished.
There is a remarkable generosity in that. He can place a petty man, a frightened woman, a dishonest lover or a tired worker in a song and give them the seriousness usually reserved for heroes. The stories do not always end well. The hopes are frequently ridiculous. But the lives are never trivial.
I still hear the astonishing forward motion of Born to Run. I also hear the years that came after it, when every road has acquired a toll and the people in the car know what is waiting at home. That's what keeps me listening. Not the fantasy that music will save us, but the knowledge that somebody else has felt the same private shame, the same stubborn affection, the same unreasonable belief that tomorrow deserves another try.