Back to John Thomas Donnelly’s journal

The People Who Are Still There When the Money Is Gone

John Thomas Donnelly ·

When I think of John Steinbeck, I don't begin with the Nobel Prize or with a schoolroom argument about the American Dream. I think of somebody making a meal out of very little, somebody else who knows how to get a motor running, and a third person who has no business asking for help but asks anyway. Steinbeck understood that people have to live together long before they learn to approve of one another.

That is one of the reasons I love Cannery Row. It has rooms that smell of work and old food. There are foolish schemes, practical jokes, little economies, accidents of generosity and people who would not pass an examination in good behaviour. Mack and the boys are not cleaned up for the benefit of the reader. They are allowed to be lazy, inventive, selfish, devoted and occasionally splendid. A party meant as an act of kindness can become a catastrophe. Another kindness must be found after the wreckage.

Doc is central to the book, but not because he has arrived to explain the other people. He belongs to them and is also apart from them. They recognize something in him they cannot quite express. Steinbeck lets their admiration come out through a ridiculous amount of trouble, which seems to me a more convincing declaration of affection than a page of fine sentiments.

That comic intelligence can be overlooked when people treat Steinbeck as a solemn champion of the poor. He could be very funny indeed. He knew how pride makes a man choose an absurd solution rather than accept an obvious favour. He could hear the pleasure people take in outsmarting one another, even when nobody is winning anything worth having.

There is no contradiction between that humour and The Grapes of Wrath. The Joad family moves through the immense cruelty of displacement, work and hunger, but the novel never entirely loses interest in bread, transport, a place to sleep, who gets the next portion and who can be trusted to do the next job. Material things are not background. They are the daily shape of the moral question. It is much easier to admire human dignity in a speech than to recognize it when three people need the same blanket.

Steinbeck understood what it costs to travel in the hope of being paid for your labour. He understood the insult of discovering that your willingness to work is not, by itself, valuable to the people employing you. And he knew that hardship does not automatically turn a person into a saint. The poor can be mean to one another, the comfortable can be generous, and a moral decision sometimes arises from nothing more dramatic than having half a sandwich left.

Of Mice and Men is almost unbearably precise about the bargains friendship makes with circumstances. George and Lennie carry an imagined home between them. It is small, practical and detailed enough to be believed in, which makes it dangerous. The dream is not a decorative symbol. It is how they get through the present day. Steinbeck respects the comfort it gives them while understanding what it cannot protect.

Then I return to East of Eden, which has an altogether different appetite. Families accumulate injuries over time. Parents misunderstand children, children inherit grudges they cannot account for, and the desire to be loved becomes confused with the desire to win. The book is occasionally expansive to the point of argument. I forgive it because the argument has blood in it. Steinbeck is trying to understand why people with room to choose still repeat the very acts that made them miserable.

I am particularly drawn to the distinction between a character being explained and a character being understood. Steinbeck sometimes reaches for an explanation, but at his best he gives us the ordinary circumstances that make an action comprehensible without making it admirable. A man can steal because he is hungry and still have stolen. A friend can betray another out of fear and remain responsible for the betrayal. Compassion isn't a legal pardon.

I have tried to keep that distinction alive in my own stories. The interesting pressure is not simply what a person does in the decisive moment but what they do afterwards, when the scene has finished and the ordinary world expects them to go on behaving normally.

Steinbeck never forgot that the ordinary world was populated. His people have neighbours, creditors, children, friends who borrow tools and strangers who might offer a lift. Even when someone is badly alone, the loneliness takes place among others. That is why a work of his can be harsh without feeling cold.

His anger matters to me, but so does the care he takes over a shabby, hilarious, inconvenient human community. Someone will be broke by morning. Someone will do the wrong thing. Someone else will come around with food, or a joke, or a hand on the broken machine. Steinbeck believes those small acts are worth describing with all the seriousness of a great historical event. I think he's right.

Continue reading

Join the Reading List

New essays, book announcements and occasional notes about the work behind the books.

Join the Reading List