Back to John Thomas Donnelly’s journal
The Man Who Couldn't Leave Himself Out
There are writers whose company you enjoy and writers you argue with while you're reading them. Norman Mailer belongs to the second group. I would not have wanted him at every dinner, but I would have wanted to hear what he said before I decided whether to invite him back.
He was capable of immense perception and immense foolishness, sometimes within the same paragraph. That is not an excuse for the foolishness. Some of his conduct and public positions were ugly, and a reader is under no obligation to disguise that in order to admire the writing. What makes him worth reading is not the myth of the difficult genius. It is the unsettling spectacle of a writer who repeatedly made his own ego part of the evidence.
I first think of the physical authority of The Naked and the Dead. A group of men under military pressure, with the hierarchies of civilian life stripped down and rearranged by rank, fear and opportunity. Mailer isn't content to tell us that war reveals character. He knows it can deform character, reward cruelty and turn small humiliations into systems. In those pages, power has a voice and a body. You can hear who is permitted to interrupt whom.
What I admire is the refusal to make everyone on the page agreeable. Much contemporary writing seems frightened of allowing an important character to think a stupid thought in a convincing way. Mailer was not frightened of that. He allowed arrogance to talk at length and sometimes gave it enough intelligence to become dangerous.
His greatest formal trick may be in The Armies of the Night. He covers the 1967 March on the Pentagon and makes “Mailer” a character in the story, observed from outside, grandiose one minute and faintly ridiculous the next. It would have been easy to present himself as the fearless witness at the centre of history. Instead, the book lets us watch him wanting to be that man, and failing to sustain the pose. The self-importance is real, but so is the comedy of exposing it.
That move matters to me as a writer. A narrator can have magnificent language and still be unreliable about himself. He can stand in the middle of an event and be wrong about his importance to it. The writer's task is not always to correct the narrator. Sometimes the task is to place enough evidence around him that the reader does the correction alone.
Mailer also knew that power is intimate. It isn't confined to institutions. It lives in the way one person corners another in conversation, uses a fact at the wrong moment, or claims the right to tell the story of a room. A courtroom, a barracks, a marriage and a political rally are not the same place, but the struggle over who gets to define reality can feel surprisingly similar.
The Executioner's Song demands another kind of attention. Its accumulation of interviews, places, routines and people around Gary Gilmore refuses the neat architecture a lesser book might impose on the material. There is a terrible momentum to the ordinary arrangements. Forms are completed. Calls are made. People arrive and wait. The machinery of a life and a death advances through details nobody has the luxury of finding symbolic.
I have always been drawn to stories in which a file, an official statement or an institution claims to have settled an argument that remains very much alive among the people who were there. The record exists, but it is not the truth in any complete human sense. Someone has chosen what can be entered. Someone else has to live with what was left out.
Mailer could overreach, and he could make an intelligent observation sound like a declaration from a mountain. I often disagree with his interpretation of what he has just shown me. Oddly, that disagreement can make the reading experience more valuable. He has brought me into the argument rather than demanding a respectful silence in front of literature.
I don't look to him for the well-adjusted sentence or the consoling view of human nature. I go back for the pressure, the scale, the belief that prose ought to risk something. It can be excessive and still discover a truth a more cautious writer would never approach.
The best Mailer makes me stop in the middle of a page, object to what he has said, and then admit that I have seen the thing he is describing. I can live without liking the man. I would rather not be without the argument.