Back to John Thomas Donnelly’s journal
The Life Somebody Else Seems to Be Having
Irwin Shaw could make a man walk into a hotel lobby and give you the feeling that the rest of his life might change before he reached the desk. That is a gift, and writers sometimes undervalue it because it looks so easy on the page.
He understood clothes, restaurants, money, travel, attractive strangers and the peculiar optimism that can descend on a person after a drink. I have always been susceptible to that kind of writing, provided the writer also knows what happens when the bill comes. Shaw knew. The expensive surfaces were never quite the subject. They were the means by which people concealed what they were missing.
In Rich Man, Poor Man, the Jordache family does not sit still long enough to become a sociological example. The brothers and their sister are forever making their choices, finding an opening, losing one, wanting a life that somebody else seems to be having. The novel has an appetite that people now sometimes dismiss as commercial. I find that dismissal odd. Making the reader want to know what happens next is not a lesser craft. It is one of the most difficult things in the business.
Shaw was willing to let people desire money without delivering a lecture about capitalism, and to let them desire sex without pretending it was always an expression of their finest selves. His characters enjoy themselves. They make foolish entrances. They judge a room quickly, often wrongly. When success comes, it brings new opportunities to behave badly rather than an improved character.
There is a particular intelligence in his short story “The Girls in Their Summer Dresses.” A married couple takes a walk in New York. The husband looks at other women, and what might be a trivial domestic exchange begins to expose a serious difference in what the marriage means to each of them. Shaw understands how an ordinary afternoon can turn without an affair, a confession or a slammed door. The wound is in the answer the wife gets to a question she almost wishes she hadn't asked.
That precision is easy to miss if you've only met Shaw through the scale of the novels. In the stories, a shift in conversation can matter as much as an event. People do not announce that they have been hurt. They start proposing other plans for the day, or say something perfectly reasonable in a tone that makes the room smaller.
The Young Lions showed another side of him. War strips away some of the protections supplied by money and charm, although not the human ability to misunderstand one's own motives. Shaw's interest in the individual survives the size of the catastrophe around him. He never asks us to admire war because it supplies grand material. He wants us to watch what particular men do with fear, privilege and duty.
And then Evening in Byzantium returns us to a world of elegant surfaces, this time around a film festival in Cannes. Its film producer has the outward life of a man who has won. Inside, the balance sheet is less reassuring. I am not sure there is an age at which that situation stops being recognizable. At twenty you look at the man in the good suit and envy him. Much later you begin to wonder what the suit is concealing.
I love the fact that Shaw can be funny without insisting on being a comic novelist. He knows the vanity of the man who believes a younger woman's attention has restored his youth. He knows the woman who sees straight through that vanity and is too tired to explain it to him. His people can be attractive and foolish at the same time, which is approximately how most of us live.
I have an affection for fiction that moves through the world rather than remaining in a single airless room of psychological significance. People in Shaw take taxis, order lunch, cross cities, make appointments, go to work. They are alive to the next invitation. Sometimes the next invitation is the trouble.
That is close to one of my own preoccupations: the way a person's ordinary performance of competence, desire or good manners can become difficult to maintain once something consequential happens. A character cannot live on insight alone. He has to find his coat, answer the telephone, and decide whether he is going to tell the truth when the other person arrives.
Shaw lets the reader enjoy those movements. That pleasure is not superficial. It puts you close enough to the characters to care when a small betrayal begins to matter.
Not every Shaw novel succeeds equally. But he saw no conflict between serious observation and being wonderfully readable. He could take you into a room you wanted to enter and make you notice, a little too late, why somebody in it was unhappy.