Back to John Thomas Donnelly’s journal
The Chair Nobody Throws Out
Before you throw out the chair, turn it over. This is sound advice if you are looking for a maker’s mark, a lost coin or the reason it leans to the left. It is less useful if the reason it remains in the house has nothing to do with carpentry. The person objecting to its removal probably knows about the leg. They have been putting cardboard under it for years.
I rather like the argument about a chair. A family can conduct it with considerable energy while avoiding almost everything it is actually arguing about. Is the room to belong to the people living in it now? Who gets to decide what counts as rubbish? And why is the person who lives elsewhere suddenly the greatest authority on the arrangement of the sitting room?
That last person is worth watching. They arrive with a useful opinion about space, open a cupboard, find the cup nobody uses and become a conservation society. Meanwhile somebody who has dusted the cup every Saturday would quite like a shelf for the things used on Sunday. Both have a case. Neither will present it particularly well.
There is a tiresome habit of granting old objects the dignity we withheld when they were new. An ugly chair becomes an heirloom by surviving the people who complained about it. A bad picture acquires importance because nobody can remember who gave it to whom. Age does not improve upholstery, and it has a mixed record with pictures. Somebody ought to mention this before the speeches begin, although it will do nothing for their popularity.
Still, the case for throwing something out can be rather smug. The new chair will be more comfortable. It will fit the room. It will have no need of cardboard. All excellent, but perhaps comfort was never the old chair’s only employment. Someone knew where to find its occupant. Someone could tell from the angle of the newspaper whether interruption was welcome. There are arrangements that disappear when the furniture changes, although the furniture was not what made them matter.
Here sentimentality can get to work with disgraceful speed. A worn armrest, an absent hand, and the chair is beyond criticism. The hand may have been kind. It may also have belonged to somebody who occupied the best chair and expected the rest of the household to work around him. Before the chair is promoted to family monument, there is the matter of who brought the tea. And who had the other seat. And whether anyone was allowed to turn the radio down, particularly during the news.
Keeping the chair need not settle that account. Neither does getting rid of it. There is room for affection without pretending the room was fair. What bothers me is the demand that a practical decision deliver a final verdict on a person, as though sending a piece of furniture to the tip were a declaration that thirty years had meant nothing.
Perhaps move it first. Put it in another room and discover whether anybody follows it. Repair the leg if someone is going to sit there; memory is no reason to give a visitor a bruised backside. If nobody wants it, ask the person who has been cleaning around it what they would put in its place. Then give them time to answer. They may already have the measurements.