Back to John Thomas Donnelly’s journal

The Beautiful Version of the Story

John Thomas Donnelly ·

The first time you read The Great Gatsby, it is tempting to think the subject is wealth. The houses, parties, clothes and cars take up so much space that money appears to be doing all the work. Later, the question becomes more uncomfortable: what happens when a man has spent his life improving the setting for a conversation that the woman he loves may never want to have?

That is the Fitzgerald I love, the one who can give longing an expensive address and still make it feel lonely.

Gatsby's achievement is extraordinary, but it is also embarrassingly specific. He has built an entire life around the hope that another person will recognize a version of him she once knew. I don't mean that he is merely deluded or that Daisy is merely cruel. Fitzgerald does not offer that simple bargain. He gives Gatsby something magnificent in the very stubbornness of his hope, while showing how little reality has been permitted to interfere with it.

Nick Carraway is crucial to the trick. His voice wants to be fair, and he likes to believe he can distinguish genuine feeling from the cheap theatre around him. Sometimes he can. Sometimes his admiration makes him an accessory to the performance. The book becomes more interesting when you stop treating the narrator as the official guide and begin asking what it costs him to be charmed.

I have always admired Fitzgerald's ability to make an ordinary social embarrassment seem decisive. A guest says the wrong thing, somebody enters a room too late, a host tries too hard. The glamour doesn't disappear. It becomes painful because everyone present understands the rules and one person has suddenly shown how desperately he wants to belong.

That may be why his sentences feel so alive to me. They are alert to the difference between what a person thinks a gesture means and what the gesture actually reveals. He can notice a voice changing when money enters the conversation. He can make somebody's good manners sound like a refusal. The words remain elegant, but the observation underneath is anything but decorative.

In Tender Is the Night, the stakes become darker. Dick Diver has gifts, charm and professional authority, yet the life he is managing begins to claim the very capacities that made him attractive. Nicole is not simply there to illustrate his decline. Their marriage contains history, dependency, power and a long confusion about who is caring for whom. I find this a more adult kind of tragedy than the idea of a promising man being ruined by one bad decision. A decline can take place gradually, through concessions that seem perfectly reasonable at the time.

Then there is “Babylon Revisited,” which compresses an entire reckoning into a man's return to Paris. Charlie Wales wants his daughter back and hopes the people who remember his former life will agree that he has changed. It is a cruel situation because the claim may be sincere, while the damage he caused remains real. He cannot simply announce that he has become another person and expect the world to revise its records.

This is what connects Fitzgerald to my own interest in intimate consequences. The question inside They Called It Love Anyway is not whether feeling can be intense or beautiful. It is what happens after the explanation has been made, when someone injured by that feeling has a different account. The person who thinks he has earned a new beginning is rarely the only one entitled to an opinion.

Fitzgerald knew the danger of treating the past as a room you can hire again if you have enough money. He also knew the sadness of the person who cannot stop trying. There is tenderness in that understanding, but very little comfort.

He is sometimes reduced to a handsome emblem of the Jazz Age, as if the parties were the lasting discovery. They are not. His great subject is the distance between the story people want to tell about their lives and the life they have actually lived. The elegance of the language makes the distance more painful, not less.

I've noticed that some writers become less interesting once you understand their principal concerns. Fitzgerald works in the opposite direction. The more plainly I see what Gatsby wants, the more frightening his devotion becomes. The more I understand Dick Diver's charm, the less safely I can admire it. The more Charlie insists on change, the more I remember the other people who have not been able to forget.

Fitzgerald lets the beautiful version dazzle us. Then the music stops, and we're still in the room with the people who have to pay for it.

Continue reading

Join the Reading List

New essays, book announcements and occasional notes about the work behind the books.

Join the Reading List