Back to John Thomas Donnelly’s journal

A Joke That Knows Exactly Who Gets Hurt

John Thomas Donnelly ·

Kurt Vonnegut can make me laugh at something and feel ashamed of laughing a moment later. I don't take that as a trick played on the reader. He has usually arranged for the joke to reveal a fact I've been avoiding.

In his books, governments are ridiculous, corporations are ridiculous, the language of expertise is ridiculous, and ordinary people behave with an astonishing talent for making things worse. But the ridicule doesn't float above the ground. Somebody pays for every splendid mistake. A person loses a job or a home. A city burns. A life that deserved attention receives a form letter.

Slaughterhouse-Five may look at first like a book determined to escape its own subject. Billy Pilgrim moves through time, the absurd machinery of the story interrupts chronology, and the human mind appears to have found elaborate ways to step aside from unbearable experience. Yet the destruction of Dresden stays with the book no matter how often the narrative leaves it. Vonnegut's refusal to arrange catastrophe into a noble, improving sequence is part of the force. There is no prize for surviving a war. There is survival, and then the rest of a life.

That strikes me as truer than the convention in which a character is wounded, learns the correct lesson and leaves the final chapter equipped for wisdom. Real experience can remain senseless. A man might know exactly what happened and never find a satisfactory explanation. Comedy, in that setting, is not disrespect. Sometimes it is the last available form of honesty.

In Cat's Cradle, the idea of ice-nine is wonderfully clear and completely horrifying. A piece of scientific ingenuity can turn the whole world into a problem nobody is equipped to solve. The invented religion around it is funny because it is so recognizably human: people need stories by which to live, even when they suspect the stories are not literally true. Vonnegut is suspicious of claims to authority, especially when the person making them believes intelligence has excused him from responsibility.

Breakfast of Champions takes another route. It strips people down to bodily and mechanical facts, uses drawings that look almost childishly simple, and keeps reminding us how much behaviour is driven by conditions the respectable account would rather ignore. The effect can be rude and unsettling. It is also a rebuke to the grand story people tell about their independence and control.

What I love most, though, is his underlying courtesy toward people who are not doing particularly well. He may mock an institution for pages and then give one bewildered person a moment of attention the institution never offered. He knows that a person can be foolish without deserving contempt. You can write a harsh book about the world and still refrain from treating the lonely as a joke.

That distinction matters to me. An institution can take what it can classify and begin to act as though classification were understanding. Vonnegut would recognize that manoeuvre, although he might have made it funnier and therefore, in some ways, worse.

His books also remind me that a novel doesn't have to wear a solemn expression to count as serious art. Fiction can be strange, fragmented, blunt and apparently irresponsible, provided there is intelligence behind the freedom. Readers are often asked to accept a good deal of dullness in the name of importance. Vonnegut declined the arrangement.

Not every joke of his lands equally for me. Sometimes the irritation in the voice begins to tell the reader what to think before the scene has had time to do its own work. The books can lecture, even while mocking lecturers. I don't see any reason to pretend otherwise. Affection survives disagreement, and in Vonnegut's case disagreement may be part of the intended experience.

What I cannot dismiss is the tenderness that keeps escaping his machinery. The person caught in a system did not build it. The unlucky do not become less human because their stories sound absurd. And the world is not made better by our ability to describe exactly how it has failed them.

I love Vonnegut because laughter in his work never quite closes the account. You laugh, and then you remember who was standing in the room. The joke goes on being funny, but it isn't harmless anymore.

Continue reading

Join the Reading List

New essays, book announcements and occasional notes about the work behind the books.

Join the Reading List